Pietisten

Vol. XIII, No. 2 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Summer 1998

Pietism and the Future

by Ryan Eikenbary-Barber

Churches often worry about being meaningful for the next generation. When a church becomes irrelevant to its young people, death is certain. Some churches try to reach their children and attract new people from the community through building projects, youth ministry, outreach events, singles groups, or contemporary services. These efforts succeed or fail based on how well they can communicate faith in the language of the new generation.

My generation, the often maligned Generation X, doesn’t find church particularly relevant. Generation X are the children of the Baby-Boomers, most often defined as people born between 1965 and 1976. Newsweek, June 20, 1998 reports that we are finally heading down the church aisles to get married, but not many couples stick around after the ceremony.1 Kevin Graham Ford, an author on the character of Generation X, cites a Barna report that reveals that 91% of my generation believes in God, but only a small portion of that number bothers with church.

Mercifully, the topic of Generation X has been missing from the front pages for a while. The most accurate generalization about people my age is that we are tired of mean-spirited articles about us featuring nicknames like “Slackers,” “Baby Buster,” the “Thirteenth Generation,” and of course “Generation X.” While there are no universal attributes to any generation, there are some unique trends in our generation. We are much more interested in spirituality than our parents, but most Busters have no commitment to the Christian Church. We are well-educated, but the majority of Generation X will not do as well financially as their parents. Kevin Graham Ford claims that our famous dark world view can be described in three negative assumptions, 1) “The world is not user-friendly,” 2) “not simple,” and 3) “has no rules.”2

If the Church wants to be relevant to Generation X and beyond it must allow the Word to address current needs. Forget slick marketing techniques and the proven methods of evangelism. What every generation craves is the message in their own language.

I believe that the Covenant Church is uniquely situated to reach young people today because of its Pietist heritage. Attributes of Pietism seem to correlate naturally with the demographic traits of the so-called “Baby Busters.” Spener, Francke, Zinzendorff, Waldenström, and Nyvall have something to say to my generation. Philip Jacob Spener, a pastor and a theologian, was concerned that Christian life was on the decline in Germany way back in the 1670s. He wrote an introduction to a collection of letters by John Arndt that was so popular that it was later published on its own. Pious Desires is the blueprint of Pietism and gives a simple six-part declaration of its goals. It seems to me that all six of Spener’s goals could impact contemporary American culture, just as they did in Sweden 150 years ago and in Germany 300 years ago. I suspect that these six goals will probably keep on speaking for generation after generation.

Goal #1: More Extensive Use of the Word of God.

Spener was concerned that the Word of God had fallen into disuse so he proposed that individuals group together to read the Bible in community outside of church. While Spener encouraged the pastor to be a part of the group, his goal was that individuals would be able to speak openly and freely about their beliefs and any doubts they had concerning difficult texts. These conventicles worked in community to determine the truth of the text.

Biblical literacy is diminishing with each generation, and yet there is a renewed demand for Biblical education. Even atheists want to read the Bible as good literature. The idea of a Bible study outside the walls of church should be appealing to many members of my generation. Contrary to Baby Boomer individualism, my generation seeks deep friendships that will help us grow. Spener’s idea of the conventicle feeds our need for the Biblical story, but also gives us a community that is free to dialogue about the meaning of the text. A casual group that reads the Bible is also less intimidating than an organized worship service.

Goal #2: The Diligent Exercise of the Spiritual Priesthood.

Spener was a good Lutheran. He was frustrated that his church had forgotten that one of Martin Luther’s chief concerns was the priesthood of all believers. Ministry and the spiritual life are not just the domain of the pastor, but of all Christians. Each person must take responsibility of their own spiritual life in order to support the work of the ordered clergy.

The spiritual priesthood was attractive to Christians in Spener’s day because of the new rise of individualism. Our culture is radically individualistic. While my generation seeks community, they also need to be empowered as individuals. Putting the minister on a pedestal is a good way to alienate anyone born after World War II—we tend to distrust authority figures. Sharing ministry may be just the way to get my generation to commit to church. Focusing on spiritual growth might be the way to demonstrate the relevance of the church.

Goal #3: Practice Above Knowledge.

Spener’s third proposal encouraged active faith among the believers. Since he was convinced that love was the essence of Christian life, Spener nudged believers to love their neighbors as sisters and brothers. This was the highest calling in Spener’s estimation. More important than knowledge of the catechism or the current theological debates of the day, was living a life of active love. Spener suggested that individuals find an accountability partner to help them negotiate their way through life as loving Christians.

Action speaks loudly to my generation. Defining Christianity as a life of love appeals to both to our sympathetic nature and our pragmatism. It fits with what Kevin Graham Ford describes as our need for a “faith that works.” While previous generations could be convinced that Christianity was worthwhile through intellectual arguments, my generation responds when it sees lives changed for the better. When Christians live out their faith in a graceful, authentic way, they have a great opportunity to reach Generation X.

Goal #4: Behavior in Religious Disagreement.

Spener lived during the close of the bloody Thirty Years War. Much evil had been committed during the war in the name of Jesus Christ. Spener was tired of the way Christians treated fellow believers who held different views. He suggested that Christians should remain humble in religious controversy and actively love both heretics and unbelievers in hope of their conversion. His goal was that Christians would reach people through their lives, not because of effective arguments or violence.

Generation X is turned-off by arrogant believers. Anyone who claims to have a monopoly on the truth is bound to offend twenty- or thirty-somethings. If the church really wants to reach my generation, they would put aside bold arguments and simply love people into the church. North Park Seminary President and Dean Jay Phelan claims that our tradition has a “commodity of modesty.” We have been able to live together without dogma and to disagree in love because we accept that we don’t yet understand everything. This is a great asset in reaching out to us. Generation X is hungry for some truth but it is unwilling to listen to someone who pontificates. Our generation desires a church that can navigate its way in a pluralistic society with love and modesty.

Goal #5: Heartfelt Faith Above Understanding.

Spener wanted to reshape theological education. In his day seminaries were too academic and therefore produced intelligent but faithless pastors. His hope was they could be reformed so that the heart of the minister in training would be considered more important than his brain.

Generation X is attracted to ministers who are authentic, caring, trustworthy, and transparent. These are attributes of a heartfelt faith, more than academic rigor. Because my generation looks for relationships rather than answers, Spener’s ideal should be appealing.

Goal #6: Meaningful Sermons.

In Spener’s day sermons were often long and boring defenses of dogma. He hoped that preaching could be reformed so that sermons would no longer show off the preacher’s knowledge and speaking ability, but would be aimed at changing the hearts of the people in the congregation.

Heartfelt preaching is especially appropriate for twenty-somethings and younger. Ford suggests that narrative evangelism is the key to reaching Generation X. He believes that to make Christianity relevant today we must take the Gospel story and let it measure own life stories. Preachers should use both the Biblical story and common, everyday stories to make sermons theologically dynamic, culturally appropriate, and relationally effective.3 For worship to be worthwhile to my generation, sermons need to hit them in the heart and offer them hope.

There are some over-eager Covenant churches which have neglected who they are and where they have come from in order to remain meaningful for the future. I believe that if they looked into the history of our tradition they would find a gold mine of relevance for the present and the future. Generation X is a heartfelt generation. Because of our Pietist heritage we have inherited a theology that makes a lot of sense to the Baby Busters and beyond. It is a shame that any Covenant church would toss away its theological identity in order to gain wide appeal. Our theology is appealing! If any trait is universally accepted by Generation X it is authenticity. We only threaten our future when we seek to be something we are not.

1. “Down the Aisle” Newsweek, June 20th 1998, Kendall Hamilton and Pat Wingert. ↩︎

2. Ford, Kevin Graham, Jesus For a New Generation, page 135, InterVarsity Press, Downers Grove Illiois, 1995. ↩︎

3. Ibid., page 37. ↩︎