Pietisten

Vol. XIII, No. 2 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Summer 1998

Practical, Therapeutic, Theological Thought

by Penrod

Text: Bodily exercise profiteth little. — Paul of Tarsus

Motto: Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. — Sigmund Freud

Dear Editors and Readers: Well, it’s good to see that someone is reading and taking time to respond. I am amazed that someone as close to Socrates as Pietisten’s correspondent Speusippus (letter, page 19) must be, has such a positive regard for new media. I can think of two reasons for my surprise.

First, I think it true, though exceptions abound, that resistance to new ways of doing things increases with age. Speusippus (Spew-sip-pus) is about 2500 years old. Second, his skip in logic. A good result, or two, does not mean that something is necessarily a good that deserves to be accepted and supported.

But before further comment, I want to acknowledge the honor of being read by Plato himself and read with kind and serious respect. I am delighted to discover that souls, persons, continue to live and that Plato is still engaged in thinking and in enjoying the activity. This is inviting—a very pleasant prospect. It is a treat to run across this picture, through written words, of joyful life of the soul. It appears that Socrates was right in those last dialogues when he explained his refusal to escape his sentence and prolong his life.

That Socrates was right about that matter does not mean that he and Plato were right about all matters philosophical. Aristotle disagreed with Plato and Speusippus and their academy just to name one person.

Speusippus must know the Phaedrus better than I, so I proceed carefully. But, he says that Uncle wrote: “They (written words) seem to talk to you as though they were intelligent, but if you ask them anything about what they say…they go on telling you just the same things forever.” By “Uncle” he means Plato yet the one he quotes is Socrates. Is he unintentionally tipping us off that our colorful friend, Socrates, is the creation of Plato’s imagination as some have suggested and not a real person? I hope not. But even if Socrates is a creation of Plato’s literary imagination, he still has a voice intended to be separate from Plato’s own.

The argument that the ease and speed of our ability to respond to someone by e-mail—especially someone loved, family and the like—does not mean that e-mail is a good thing overall. It might be, but concluding that it is from this example is like saying faith healing should always be encouraged and a base scoundrel allowed to continue without criticism because a few people have been healed by her.

The particularities of e-mail aside, the real hazard of our technology is speed. The speed at which we currently move and live is dangerous and likely to kill us. When I say this, I fear I am whistling in the wind. Nobody ever takes me up on it. The only one I know of for sure who understands this danger and its dynamics is Ivan Illyich (Tools for Conviviality). I know he understands because he explained it to me.

This thought came to me the other day: Haste fuels hostility. Take driving to work, the daily experience of many. The less time one has, the closer to being late, the more others in their cars with people on their pilgrimages, become obstacles. As they do, they become the opposition, our enemies. The very same comrades at thirty-miles-per-hour with plenty of time are friends along the way toward whom one is filled with the milk of human kindness and whom one greets politely.

Clearly, the hazard is not motion itself; speed is relative. Appropriate, pragmatic speed is the goal. Pragmatic speed, in the large scheme of human life, is the speed whose primary objective is a pace that fosters the blessing of personal life. Socrates and Earl Schwartz both help us remember this.