Pietisten

Vol. XIII, No. 2 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Summer 1998

Adult Children of God

by Elder M. Lindahl

At the close of a class on psychology of religion in a seminar for seniors some time ago, one of the students, a gentleman in his 70s, raised a good question. The teacher had lectured on the relationship between religious faith and psychology, and had during the lectures and discussions testified to his own times of suffering and his trust in God who supplied his needs and sustained him day by day. With deep emotion, he told us of his struggles and his dependency on God. The student, who had followed closely and was obviously himself devout, raised his hand and asked simply, “How do human development and self-reliance come into the picture?” Time did not permit an answer, so the question was left swinging in mid air.

There is a serious indictment of the Church in his question. The Church, for all its positive strengths, has paid little attention to human development and human self-reliance. It has promoted emotional dependency on God and other people more than emotional independency and self-confidence. Christians are often encouraged to think they have a divine right to be taken care of—protected, kept secure, guided, given good health and all. God will, like a good shepherd, supply our every need and keep us safe from harm. Promoting dependency and obedience, as the Church frequently does, undergirds childish attitudes and impedes the development of normal emotional strengths, coping capacities, and wisdom which permit us to function as adults. Dependency is deeply ingrained in the message of the Church. Christians, we have heard so often, are supposed to be dependent children.

Psychologist Sigmund Freud claimed that religious people can never grow emotionally beyond the state of childhood helplessness and dependency. Religion, including Christian Faith, was, for him, regression to an infantile stage of helplessness, a neurosis. It is the projection of a Heavenly Father who loves us, will take care of us, solve our problems, and will finally reward us with eternal life. Religious people, he argued, are fated to be children forever.

In contrast to those who, in one way or another, connect childhood emotions with the Christian Faith, I contend that human development and self-reliance have an essential place in the faith picture. Normal human growth—physical and emotional—are essentials in the Divine intention. Growing up to handle whatever comes in life is, I believe, good and pleasing to God. Like a wise parent, God desires that His children fulfill their potential. Like a prudent parent, God does not want His children to be dependents forever. What is the point of all the God-given potential, the decision-making capacities, and the drives to maturity, if God intended that we remain dependent forever? Growth occurs as we take increased responsibility for what is happening in our lives. And it is important to remember that the wonderful potential in humans to change from helpless infants to free-standing, independent adults is a gift which God graciously gives us in creation.

Development begins in the womb. In time, as children grow, they come to distinguish themselves from the environment and from other people, and recognize themselves as unique identities with assertive wills. They begin to see themselves as persons with power and authority to choose foods, clothes, toys, and so on. I remember our granddaughter, Anne, about age two, saying with absolute determination and self-reliance, “Anne do it!” There was no question—a unique, self-confident individual, with an already firm sense of herself, was asserting her will and her ability to handle a job. The “battle for autonomy,” according to developmental psychologists begins early and continues with the transition into adulthood.

In this “battle for autonomy,” parents, because of their authority, strength, and necessary role, have the edge. Mature parents, just the same, will encourage their offspring, whenever they can, in the development of emotional strengths, self-confidence, and self-reliance so that they will eventually take responsibility, make their own moral decisions, and have their own viewpoints. That same encouragement should happen in schools, churches, organizations, and in society generally.

The natural process of emotional development is very complex— it involves many different facets of a life. Some of the problems associated with stunted emotional development, however, could be said to be created by the Church. “Trust and obey,” an important message for little ones, hardly encourages mature adults to take responsibility for their lives and decisions. Children require authority, discipline, rewards, and punishment in the early growth stages. From a developmental point of view, however, obedience to authority, though of necessity acceptable for children, is problematic for adults. Whether the question centers on obedience to the authority of parents, Pope, state, pastors, youth leaders, Bible, saints, God, or whomever—the issue of individual responsibility is basic. In obedience relationships, the one in authority thinks of himself or herself as an agent or instrument charged with the responsibility of another’s life. An obedient person is called “good,” or “spiritual” insofar as he or she faithfully executes the will of another. The “self” of a person who is under obligation to an authority is not autonomous.

Also, there are some negative effects of the commandment “trust and obey” for both children and adults. We have all read and heard of sexual abuses, and financial schemes to defraud and mislead victims in all areas of our society—schools, churches, and organizations. Those in authority who take personal advantage of “obedience relationships” do great harm and bring lasting pain. Everyone needs to be encouraged to think critically and make decisions carefully.

How would it be if we as grown-ups in the Church were exhorted to think about God as a Heavenly Father who enjoys watching us grow, develop, make our own decisions, and handle whatever comes in the adventure of life? How would it be if we heard from the pulpit that God desires the congregants to become adults—mature, strong, and autonomous—actualizing the God-given developmental capacities? How would it be if we as adults were encouraged to change our prayers from requests for God to solve our every problem—cure me, protect me, help me, and so on—to prayers for communion with God, seeking God’s presence and strength as we cope with circumstances the best we can to the glory of God’s name?

We grow as we face difficulties, solve problems, and cope with situations in our own strength and through our own resources, just as we did as children coming to adulthood. If God solves all our problems, fixes every struggle, meets every need, and confronts every challenge for us, we simply will not grow and develop the strength and the capacity to solve life’s problems maturely. We will never become fully human adults if someone else, even God, controls our lives. Growth occurs as one uses one’s own resources and abilities in struggling to deal with the common experiences that come with the human condition.

I believe that Christians as mature self-reliant people will be able to handle the contingencies of life as adult children of God, and, in the midst of it all, praise, worship, and celebrate the greatness of the One who gives life and sets before us the challenge of fellowship with Him. God’s desire for us in this created order is that we grow up into full personhood, exercise the capacities to choose, and attain the emotional strength to live with the consequences of those choices.

It’s wonderful to see growth in Christian self-reliance. A fine Christian woman and personal friend of mine who has been heroically fighting cancer for some twenty-five years experienced a whole new perspective on how to deal with her situation. She has written a book and has given many edifying talks to various groups about coping with cancer. In the early stages of her illness, she prayed fervently that God would cure her. At some point there was a change, and she now prays for courage, strength, and wisdom to cope with her illness, omitting entirely the request for Divine healing. She accepts what she has as something that simply is, a reality to handle. Sometimes healing occurs in the natural processes of mind and body and sometimes it doesn’t. She lives peacefully in both realism and hope and is a good example of a mature Christian person. She does not ask what she did to deserve this or why God inflicted her with cancer or why God doesn’t cure her and so on. Rather, she concentrates on ways she can creatively and positively appropriate the alien, negative event that is happening to the cells of her body. When asked what I thought about the significant change in her way of praying, I said I thought it represented some new strength and maturity, some emotional growth. Her radiant spirit, ready smile, and friendly concern for others testifies to the presence of inner strength and continued belief in and fellowship with her Lord.

When people work through the childhood stages of normal development to adult experience, faith plays a key role in the integration of a complete, well-rounded personality. Faith in God that connects positively with normal growth brings meaning and wholeness to experience. When we use our God-given resources, struggle to solve our problems, test ourselves, think critically, handle our suffering with courage and wisdom, we grow stronger. Alexander Feinsilver puts it well (In Search of Maturity, p. 19):

…Mature religion is full-grown, well-rooted, sturdy, and strong. It has faced reality and met challenge. It has come to terms with psychology and sociology, geology and archaeology. These disciplines of the mind have poured their sunlight upon it, watered its roots, nurtured its shoots, beautified its flowering. Religion tested by reason does not easily wither, is not easily uprooted, does not quickly die. It has become an essential part of the individual, operating with all that he knows and sees, and integrating all of the experiences of life into one comprehensible pattern.

Yes, growth comes as we face reality and meet the challenges of life responsibly and courageously as God intended in creation. I believe that “human development and self-reliance” come into the religious faith picture through the recognition and acceptance of ourselves as God’s adult children. And I contend that Freud was wrong when he said that Christians are destined to be dependent children forever. Christians can be self-reliant people.