A Letter from Screwtape
Dear Pietisten: While going through the dusty archives at Barleyton College, Barleyton, Illinois, I came across this curious letter reminiscent of a style we can’t quite place. I thought one of your readers may be able to enlighten us. Don Norris, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
My Dear Wormwood,
While, for the most part, I approve of your recent improved methods of dealing with the Enemy through your patient, I note with concern your flippant attitude toward her dreams. There is real danger here. Are you not aware of the attention our Father has paid to this human phenomenon? Please come to your senses in this matter: recall, for example, the decades and centuries so many of your brethren have devoted to insure the proper interpretation of dreams. I grant we are in difficulty in our efforts to understand, not only how the dream presents itself to the human consciousness, but also what He had in mind when He created them to need sleep and dream. Despite this, you may be quite certain this is another of His plots that will only slowly unfold itself in future—and beware accordingly.
But to return. You reported with little elaboration on a series of dreams your patient had on the vague theme of a serious, even fatal accident occurring to her mother. While you properly fostered her reaction of thrilled horror, you did so, my dear nephew, in ignorance. You do not realize that you, assigned to the daughter, and Glubgob, assigned to the mother, have your two charges as close to choosing our Father’s way as they have ever been. Should you be ultimately successful, I would have no hesitancy in recommending your moving down in the underarchy; that is, if you know what you are about.
Now the fragility of the human mind-body-spirit makeup is well known. In some way unknown to us, He uses one kind of dream to renew them, to restore the essence of that lowly trinity, so that, as you are well aware, very often the good work we accomplish on one day must begin anew the next. The images that present themselves to the sleeper are but fleeting and appear simply to replay with variation the mundane activities of the day. There seems no way, given the state of our present knowledge, to turn this dream type to advantage. On the other hand, the human who recalls any images of such a dream is so rare as to make a concentrated effort on our part a waste.
However, the kind of dream your patient had is of a quite different order. It would be most dangerous to us if it were not for the quality of our work that I mentioned. You must know that when these humans were created, He hoped to plant within them a consciousness of their failure to live up to some vague goal of idealized behavior. He planned that they should feel dissatisfaction in their inability to attain this goal and that this, in turn, would perhaps serve as a clue to their source. Yes, dear nephew, I sense your impatience. You feel you already know this very well indeed. But please note I am applying these observations to the dream state, while you are familiar only with “conscience” as found in the waking state. Now you see the true extent of our problem in battling this two-pronged attack of the Enemy. It is really unfair! I hope for your sake this background has shown you the height of your stupidity. You can be certain those responsible for your education before I took you in hand will suffer such wonderful anguish! I shall see to it myself. Please pay attention now, while I summarize the methods found most successful in combating the dream. You may take it that any dream rising to the normal human consciousness will be amenable to these methods:
First, you must try to dispel any clear recollection of the dream upon awakening, using whatever device suggests itself to you: for example, immediate concerns for the cares of the day will be found useful. The great thing is to induce a reaction of complete unreality, a revulsion of feeling against even pleasurable remnants of the dream as having no point of contact with the “true” states of the patient. Alienation is the operative word. Except for the most vivid of phantasms you will find a sustained attack unnecessary; the threads of dream constituents will sink quickly into disarray under their own weight, never to be recalled. Should the patient resist us, or the dream elements prove too powerful, then the second rank of forces must be brought into line— deception. Under that collective head are to be found our most favorable armaments: analysis of dreams by the various schools of thought, all of which are already at variance; superstitions we have kept alive—the specious heritage of mythic elements; confusion of the source of dream as reflecting the dark side, or negative facets of human nature. In short, any formal or informal method must be used.
But I fear such a sustained and logical dissertation is taxing your powers of concentration, never great from your youth, so, dear nephew, I postpone the argument until a more suitable time.
Your affectionate uncle,
Screwtape
