Touching Some Nerves
Where did I ever get the idea that the music which soothes our souls is non-controversial? On my first Sunday as an interim ‘minister in a United Church of Christ, we dedicated the “denomination’s new hymnbook, The New Century Hymnal. 1 admit I am struggling with it a bit. One Sunday we were singing “O Mighty God.” I started belting it out like a Pavaratti, only to swallow my words and struggle with eight verses of utterly new words and phraseology. How could they do this to Boberg and the Swedes?
A recent news story blasted the UCC for the hymnal. Many good brothers and sisters in UCC churches concur. Old chestnuts fell on the cutting floor. Hymns on social justice came in heavy. Many older songs had radically changed wording. Yet, I was surprised to see an old song like “I Must Tell Jesus” unchanged. Few eschatological hymns survived. A judicious mixture of praise songs and spirituals were added for balance. My complaint is a seemingly inordinate number of hymns with which I have no acquittance. Someday congregations may sing a new hymn like “The Baptist Shouts on Jordan’s Shore,” but I doubt that will be soon. Closer to my heart of hearts is what’s been done to a familiar hymn. “What a Fellowship, What a Joy Divine” has been retitled “What a Covenant, What a Joy Divine.”
I have always felt that we should try to communicate the good news of Christ in language people understand. New ways of putting the message, whether in word or song, can save us from mindless assents to faith which we do not understand. But there is more to our experience than relevance. An evangelical professor friend of mine, tired of the way everything is tied to practical results in the church—to what works and what doesn’t work —has turned to the historic Orthodox Church. Here he finds meaning in the ancient mystery. Here he celebrates creation and finds Christ new in worship which is as old as the hills, yet seizes him as the dawning sun.
Faith for me is engendered in holy roots. Faith is being overcome by God in the family ethos. A navy lieutenant in the big war once told me how overcome he was hearing sailors sing during a blackout the familiar, “There is Power in the Blood.” This is more than nostalgia! The New Century Hymnal highlights scripture that makes sense. “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, and today, and forever” (Hebrews. 13:8). Our identity is in God’s great ongoing story. We can’t afford to lose it.!
