Mathew 16:21-28 and Waldenstrom’s Commentary
Gospel Lesson for the Fourteenth Sunday after Pentecost
Dr. Paul Peter Waldenström based his comments on a Greek New Testament text that he translated into Swedish. Tommy Carlson has translated both the Biblical text and Waldenström’s comments from the Swedish text, 2nd Edition, 1892.
Verse 21 — From that time1 Jesus began2 to show his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem and suffer much from the elders and the high priests and the scribes and be put to death and raised again on the third day. Matt 20:17ff.
- This story is also told in Mark 8:31-33 and Luke 9:21-22. “From that time,” says the evangelist. Jesus prepared the disciples so they would be able to bear his death. The anticipated is never as hard to take as the unexpected. Compare John 13:19, 16:1.
- The Lord had previously alluded to his upcoming suffering (see 12:40; John 2:19, 10:17) but now he began to teach them its clear meaning. Peter’s answer reveals that he had not understood Jesus’ previous intimations.
Verse 22 — And Peter took him aside and began to rebuke him saying: “(God have) mercy on you, Lord. By no means shall this happen to you.”1
- Peter felt that what the Lord spoke was completely against his calling as the messiah (see also Luke 24:21). Peter would reconcile the two conceptions, “Christ, son of the living God,” on the one hand, and “crucified and dead” on the other, through the experience to follow.
Verse 23 — But he turned around and said to Peter: “Go behind me Satan1 you are an offense2 to me, for you do not have in your mind that which belongs to God,3 but rather that which belongs to man.”4
- The Lord called Peter “Satan” because he, like Satan, went against God’s counsel.
- The Savior experienced Peter’s words in the depths of his human nature as a temptation to diverge from God’s previously determined counsel. This explains the fervor, and the fierceness, with which Jesus put Peter out of his sight.
- The road of suffering was decreed by God as the road to which Christ must be obedient (Heb 5:8) and finish as the King of salvation (Heb 2:10). On this road he would defeat the Devil (Heb 2:14) and complete the work the Father had given him to do on earth (John 17:4). Peter’s mind was not aimed in that direction; such a thing he did not want.
- Peter did not wish suffering and degradation, rather he looked for a winning and gloriously reigning messiah, just as the Jewish people in general wanted.
Verse 24 — Then, Jesus said to his disciples:1 “If anyone wants to follow me, he must deny2 himself, and take his cross3 and follow me. (Matt 6:38 ff.)
- And to the people, whom he had now summoned (Mark). What precedes took place between him and the disciples only.
- He must sacrifice himself in every aspect. He cannot seek his own will, his own comfort, advantage, or anything else Just because it is pleasing to the flesh.
- Suffering up to and including the violent and degrading death on a cross can come to a disciple for Jesus’ sake. Compare 10:38. Crucifixion was a Roman death sentence and, therefore, disgraceful for a Jew.
Verse 25 — For whosoever wants to save his soul,1 shall lose it,2 but whoever loses his soul for my sake shall find it.3
- For this age.
- He who denies to save his soul for this age, shall lose it for the coming age.
- The one who, rather than deny me, gives his soul as a sacrifice for this age, shall find it in the coming age. Life will be his lot.
Verse 26 — Because what does it gain a person, if he has won the whole world1 but has lost his soul?2 Or what shall a person give as a ransom for his soul?
- Namely, for the coming age. No intelligent person sells his or her head for all the gold in the world. How much more insane is it to sell eternal life for temporal advantage?
- That is, win the soul from eternal death. The Greek word used here means EXCHANGE—what one exchanges for something else, thereby assuring it for oneself. But humankind has nothing like that to give for a soul. So, what gain is there in all the world’s goods and gold?
Verse 27 — For the Son of Man shall come in the Father’s glory1 with his angels, and then he shall reward each and every one according to their deeds.2 See Zech. 14:5; Matt 25:31, 26:64; Rom 2:6; Rev 2:23.
- The Father has given God’s own glory to the Son. The godly majesty belonging to the Father is given to the Son. In this majesty He shall come again.
- The word of the Savior expresses humankind’s actions viewed completely —not just particular actions. The work of Judgment and of salvation (John 3:17, 4:34) is given to the Son. Both are God’s work given to the Son to accomplish. See John 5:22, 27 and Acts 17:31 concerning the mutual relationship of the Father and the Son in the work of judgment.
Verse 28 — Truly I say to you that some standing here shall never taste death, until they will see the Son of Man coming with the kingdom.”1
- Some have interpreted these words to refer to the destruction of Jerusalem, but his return is described as coming back in the Father’s glory with holy angels, so this cannot mean the destruction of Jerusalem. Christ talks about his return in glory to keep them and establish that kingdom which he received from the Father (compare Luke 19:12 ff). If “taste death” means strictly “bodily death,” he is prophesying that his return will take place before all those hearing him were dead. Butin Mark 13:32 he says that he does not know the time of his return. Then there is Paul’s belief that Christ’s would return while Paul was alive (1Thes 4:17). But this is unthinkable. Therefore, to “taste death” probably means what he meant in John 8:51: “If someone keeps my word, he shall not see death in eternity.” Those “standing” would die in body, but many among them would never TASTE or SEE death. Their bodily deaths would be sleep (John 11;11) and rest (Rev 14:13) until the day when they see the Son of Man coming with his kingdom.
