Practical, Therapeutic, Theological Thought
It’s High Time
Motto: “Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.” — Sigmund Freud
The ballyhoo about this so-called journal’s tenth birthday means little to me. I assume the other “editors” concur with Johnson that the “attained age” is a “wonder to us.” Among other things, their wonder reveals that these people have not accomplished much in their lives. As for me, it is high time to address two matters regarding primary sources.
First, I want to know the primary source of the current motto for this column. It is taken from Dennis Moon’s letter to me printed in the Summer, 1994 issue, pages 19, 20. About it he wrote: “This is a response that Freud is said to have given when questioned what he, unconsciously, might be expressing by smoking cigars.” Very good. But, is there a text? If Freud did not write this statement, who did? In what? Where? I have made vigorous efforts to be responsive to readers —adopting this motto in response to a reader’s critique is an example. Now I would like something in return. In the Fall, 1995, issue, I asked Mr. Moon to provide the reference, but he has not responded.
The previous motto for this column was “All therapy ends badly,” also credited to Freud. He meant, I was told, that either the patient does not get better or does and the therapist loses the income. I thought the statement ironic and a suitable motto for this column. Moon attempted to demolish this statement and made it an occasion to take on the man from Vienna himself. I asked the psychology professor who reported these words as Freud’s where I could find them but he did not know. Therefore, I am faced with the question: Did Freud utter either of these sentences? One of you must know or be able to help. Please do. You could relieve my ignorance and the ignorance of those who share it.
Second, in spite the fact that this column has been in virtually every Pietisten of recent memory, I suspect ignorance of my model Penrod is rampant. The odds are that you have not bothered to read Booth Tarkington’s masterpiece. It was my plan to provide you with selections from the primary source so you could taste this treat, but the editors’ Pietisten anniversary priorities have curtailed space. Please treat yourself.
