Pietisten

Vol. X, No. 4 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Spring 1996

Pondering Church Unity

by Arthur W. Anderson

Friends ask me what I’m doing now. When I tell them that I’m serving two churches now —pastoring in a Presbyterian Church and preaching in a United Church of Christ, they quickly reply: “What, not golfing in Florida?” For one thing, my golf isn’t a very good reason to get out of town, and besides, in the sunny clime the green fees are too lush for my pocketbook. The truth is, I’m having more fun doing what I’m doing.

I met a man this week who said he was serving a Presbyterian church but belonged to the United Church of Christ. He added: “I’m an ecumenist.” That gave me pause and I said: “Well, I believe I am one, too.” We shook hands and blessed each other.

Working on a sermon last week on the lectionary text, I Cor. 1:10-18, I sensed a fire burning within me. Paul’s question lit the flame, “Is Christ divided?” On a busy street not far from where I live, there are four churches alongside each other, three of them quite new. Tipping my hat to the good there is in worshipping God in ways that are real to us, and recognizing the importance of diversity, I can’t help but think that to someone searching for faith, that has to be scandalous. Not only that, but they are like businesses competing for customers.

Don’t misread me. I’m not anti-denominational, nor do I think unity is one big mega-church with our preferred pope at the top. I say this because I am grateful for my church family, the Covenant Church. I am an unashamed pietist who treasures our fellowship for its commitment to being alive in Christ in the openness of freedom. What an honest and holy tradition we have! To be entrusted with the opportunities I ve had in our Covenant is a personal gift that could only have its source in the grace of heaven.

Having known this kind of love and acceptance, I have been free enough within to find myself at home in churches with other labels. Believe it or not, pietists with passion are there, too! Reflecting on my recent role as chairman of the Inter-church Relations Commission of the Covenant Church, I found myself a bit frustrated. Was the ultimate in ecumenicity joining the WCC or NAE? Was organizational unity the way? In one sense it is because, unless we legitimize unity in some form of organization, we do not cross over into fellowship with others nor do we feel any responsibility to work together in common programs. But I long for a more organismic oneness. The late Dr. Joseph Sittler said at a North Park Seminary Convocation some years ago that we are one and that this is the banquet to which we are invited. He added that God’s banquet will go on with or without us. I attended a Martin Luther King festivity in St. Patrick’s Cathedral in our city. Such music and the clarion call of young Christians made me think: “This is what heaven must be like!”