Pietisten

Vol. X, No. 4 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Spring 1996

Coincidently. . . .

by Elder M. Lindahl

“Is that you, Elder?” came a familiar voice from an adjoining chair in the lobby of the Marriott.

I looked from behind my morning newspaper to see a friend I had not seen in some three years. “What a coincidence,” he said.

Knowing my friend’s conservative theological orientation, I tested him to see if he had kept his Faith, “Coincidence—don’t you believe our meeting was providential?,” I queried.

We laughed, drank coffee, and talked about old and new times for half an hour until he had to leave to catch a plane. On saying goodbye, he “repented” and affirmed that our meeting was in fact Divinely providential.

Neither a coincidental nor a providential label for our unplanned get-together was necessary, as we were both attending the same AAR/SBL (American Academy of Religion/Society of Biblical Literature) annual meeting of some 7,000 religion scholars, teachers, and administrators in Philadelphia the weekend prior to Thanksgiving. Although I had not attended this conference since retiring from teaching in 1990, I met many old friends at the sessions, on the crowded escalators, and in the hallways.

Providence in a general sense gives me no problem. Considering the wonder of God’s provisions for us, the surfeit of nature, the marvels of the human body, the starry heavens above, and His sustaining resources at every turn, I joyfully praise Him from whom all blessings flow.

Particularized providence is something different and quite problematic. Some Christians have an amazingly detailed sense of God’s provision for them. A cornerstone of their belief is that they have an inalienable right to Divine protection and care. They claim that God helps them find keys, locate lost pets, know when to sell property, keep from accidents, find parking spaces, choose furniture, and so forth. The detail for some gets incredibly specific. Balancing the cosmos and all, the good Lord must be kept pretty busy on their behalf. Guardian Angels, no doubt, are running hither and yon taking care of them, trying to avoid massive traffic jams! Seriously, how do self-reliance and responsibility fit into such a providential scheme?

Muriel and I had just left the Dala Horse, a Swedish pancake restaurant in Kingsburg, CA, last winter when we saw some old friends from the Midwest park their car and prepare to go in. We rejoiced to see them, hugged and greeted each other. “What a coincidence—you’re supposed to be in Cleveland,” I said.

After telling us of their mission in the West, one of them said: “Just think, had we left the place where we are staying a minute earlier, driven more slowly, turned left instead of right, or eaten somewhere else, we would have missed you. How wonderful is our Lord to work out all things in such a marvelous way so that we met in this very spot at the same instant.”

We went back with them into the Dala Horse, and sat down for a second cup of coffee. We caught up on each other’s adventures and families and had a wonderful time as they enjoyed their pancakes. The meeting that day was for them but the latest instance in a whole scenario of providential occurrences. Their recurrent theme was, “We find that God guides us continually in just everything.”

I thought the theology a bit heavy, and mentioned that we actually had planned to go to Yosemite for the day, but because of the sudden illness of one of our foursome, we cancelled those plans and substituted the outing to Kingsburg instead. “So, you see,” I retorted, “to work out the details of His plans for our meeting you at the Dala Horse today, it meant His assigning a bout with the flu to one of our relatives.”

Considerations like this seem to make no difference to those committed to particularized providence. The “all things” of Romans 8:28 for them mean every last thing. There simply are no coincidences in His universe. He’s got the whole world, including us at every turn and every step, in His hands. Christians who refer to happy occurrences as flukes, happenstances, luck or chance are, for them, guilty of bad faith.

Some years ago, I remember riding along a boulevard on a Sunday morning on the way to church with some friends. After sailing through some five or six intersections on green lights, one of the passengers remarked, “Isn’t it wonderful, how God sees to it that all the lights are green when you are on the way to His House!”

Wouldn’t you know, at the next several intersections we were stopped by red lights! The facts were dead against the remark, and I wondered how this passenger would get out from under it. Our destination certainly had not changed. “But, you know,” she said, “Satan is always there to put obstacles in the way of those who are going to church!”

Her cosmic dualism provided her a “win-win” situation, even when adversity showed its ugly, red head. God was in control despite contrary events. It was as though an off/on interpretation switch was thrown whenever some unforeseen, unfortunate event appeared on the horizon. The word “coincidence” simply was not in her Christian vocabulary. Events, for her, came together by Divine destiny, a kind of sovereign fate, operative in the universe. What part, I wondered, did empirical reality and the laws of physics play in her thinking?

General providence and genuine coincidences, I believe, cohere in God’s marvelous created order. That order is manifested in the wonder and beauty of the constantly changing, multitudinous, spectacular scenes we experience. Sometimes, with the help of scientists, we can grasp the causal connections which function in the cosmic process. At other times, we, along with them, are confronted by accidental or unexpected events—sometimes neutral, sometimes trivial, sometimes pleasant, sometimes tragic—all part of the human experience.

Chance occurrences, if you think about them, play an important, even determinative, role in shaping and forming the significant pathways of one’s life. Reflect for a moment on the various turns of events, happenings, which resulted in your having a certain friend, attending specific schools, going into a particular line of work, meeting a mate, settling in a geographical area, finding an apartment, having children, affiliating with a local church, reading Pietisten, buying a certain house or vacation place, taking that trip last summer, and so on. Carl Jung coined the term, “Synchronicity” to describe meaningful occurrences that have no apparent cause, that come out of nowhere. Random happenings and events, coming out of the blue as it were, have a way to influence, solidify, and define one’s identity, vocation, and destiny.

In His benevolence, God has given us the capacity and the resources to deal with the simultaneous surprises, good and bad, which come in the course of our lifetimes. Positive, supporting events (the green lights), and negative, adverse events (the red lights) in their manifestations make for ambiguity. Confronted both by the favorable and the unfavorable, we learn to live with ambiguity and apparent contradictions even as we sing, with gusto, “This is my Father’s world.” I think God intends that we experience life just as it is so we will grow and mature. Faith, I believe, is loving God in the midst of whatever is the case in the world.