Bronson Alcott’s Daughter
On the happy day that my aunt and I visited Orchard House in Concord, Massachusetts, ninety-nine springs had passed since Louisa May Alcott sat at her bedroom desk in that house, daily writing the “story for girls” which would become Little Women. Her Publisher had pressed her for such a book, and her family owed debts which only Louisa was in a position to address, so from May to July of 1868, she wrote “steadily and with concentration,” according to her biographer, but “with none of the enthusiasm or exhilaration” that had marked her previous work.1
To explore Alcott’s life is to find that her intentions in writing her books for girls were not as clear and sunny as was the experience of her audience in reading them. Similarly, to explore the reasons why generations of women, and some men, have treasured Louisa’s idealized pictures of domestic life is to uncover personal and societal hungers that we satisfy with our recreational reading.
Her charming stories instilled in young readers like me a belief in what I already hoped for—for instance, that personal wellbeing and household harmony would be the rewards for virtue carefully cultivated. Further, Alcott’s characters could convince one, as Louisa herself needed to be convinced, that the constricted horizons of those who lack money and worldly power are not to be regretted, but triumphantly accepted.
Alcott’s books were assisted in becoming sentimental favorites by being produced at a time when authors and publishers were beginning to recognize readers as consumers, and when the technology was becoming available to reach those consumers. Her portrayals were popular in their substance because, uncritically, they affirmed people’s belief systems. She reassured moral people, for example, that morality wins the day. (Never mind providing answers for moral failure). Alcott encouraged women, in the midst of their economic and political powerlessness, to take heart from literary images of females content to be passively good, like sister Beth.
This author worked very hard, even through periods of physical illness and pain. The extent to which her books were commercially motivated she never denied. In fact, her upbringing in a financially desperate family made her very proud to have discovered how to earn a good living. She may not have been nearly as aware that her stories were a personal attempt to redeem her father’s unrealized vision of utopia.
Louisa passed on to eager readers what she herself needed to believe, because she had been taught it by her philosopher father—that to conquer personal faults was victory enough for anyone, and to influence the world indirectly by purity of intentions was a worthy calling for which women were particularly suited. Alcott also passed on what she herself rejected, namely that marriage constituted a woman’s one chance for fulfillment. She created a husband and children for “Jo,” the “little woman” who represents her, even though in real life Louisa chose not to marry. Inher novels for girls, she glorified a woman’s dependence on others, but she wrote this to her father when she was in her mid-twenties:
. . . I am very well and very happy. Things go smoothly, and I think I shall come out right, and prove that though an Alcott I can support myself. I like the independent feeling; and though not an easy life, it is a free one, and I enjoy it. I can’t do much with my hands; so I will make a battering-ram of my head and make a way through this rough-and-tumble world.2
Louisa was to find herself trapped by success. Unfettered creativity was soon no longer an option because of the expectations of her public, and publisher, for more of the same. If she turned her back on her readers, the income that supported her family would dry up. To this daughter of chronically impoverished parents, nothing would be so unacceptable as a return to destitution.
Because I could relate to the circumstances and values of its characters, the effect of Little Women on me as a young girl in the 1950s was powerful. With steadfast enthusiasm, Alcott described the blessed lives led by girls and women who, regardless of the shortcomings of parental figures, accepted their calling to beauty and usefulness; with devotion I returned to the books to feast on favorite portions and be affirmed in my own quest to be beautiful and useful. Only later would I discover the tensions — between our moral reach and our grasp; between personal gifts and ambitions and the “proper” role of women; and, most significantly, between the religiosity of the March family and the Christian Gospel as my church confessed it. Louisa May Alcott’s operative theology is a topic for another time.
My aunt and I and a few million others continue to enjoy and respect Louisa May Alcott’s books for young people. Even in adulthood I reread them to visit old fictional friends. Still, there came that point when I had to ask why a woman who was single, independent, and active in the great causes of her day, such as the abolition of slavery, could not write about her real life. Idealization of the experience of her family of origin was what she chose instead. Idealization is a form of distortion, and therefore potentially harmful. For example, as an adult still trying to be a girl or a “little woman,” I learned that there are consequences to denying the fact of personal power. One does not use power responsibly unless one is aware of having it. Is it not crucial to be aware of distortions so that ideals, which indeed serve us, can be kept in perspective?
There is a thesis about Victorian women writers, as well as about certain clergymen of the time, that their literary contributions were a bid to claim turf for the powerless in reaction to the rising power of industry in the nineteenth century. Women and ministers employed the power of the pen with ambivalent motives, which included the understandable one of self-justification.3? The result has been a lasting split between art that would be accountable to truth, and the products of mass market culture, which are accountable in more troublesome ways. No simple formula suffices for making the distinction, but it is worthwhile to ask brave questions. Popular culture can be entertaining and satisfying, while it also keeps alive inadequate or irrelevant belief systems.
