J. S. Bach in Leipzig: The City’s Response to Pietism
(Seventh in a Series)
Throughout this series, we have examined how J. S. Bach responded to the pietistic movement that was sweeping Germany during his career as a church musician. Of particular interest has been the effect of Pietism not only on the texts that Bach set, but also on the location and tenure of the positions that he sought and accepted. In the last installment, for example, I argued that Bach chose not to apply for the organist post at the Jacobikirche in Hamburg because of the virulent anti-Pietism of its pastor. More importantly, I indicated how the increasing tension between Pietist and Orthodox, as well as between Reformed and Lutheran, contributed to Bach’s decision to leave Cöthen, where he served as Capellmeister.
The position to which Bach was appointed in 1723 was in Leipzig, a city where Pietism took a course markedly different from that in either Hamburg or Cöthen. In Hamburg, a traditional Lutheran city with five major churches, the Orthodox pastors declared an all-out war on Pietism. In Cöthen, on the other hand, the Lutheran church’s patroness, Gisela Agnes, after becoming an avowed Pietist, appointed only pastors of the same persuasion. However, in Leipzig, after the movement was initially embraced and then attacked, Pietism and Orthodoxy came to coexist with one another, albeit in a precarious and ever-changing balance. After describing the rise of Pietism in Leipzig, this installment will focus on the city’s reception to the movement in the decades immediately preceding Bach’s arrival in 1723.
Spener’s influence in Leipzig and Saxony
The course of the pietistic movement in Leipzig was determined not only by the city’s religious leaders, which included the theological faculty of the University, but also by the Elector (later called King) of Saxony, whose court was located in Dresden. The court included a council, or consistorium, that had jurisdiction over all religious institutions within Saxony, including the churches of Leipzig and the University. It was to this council that Bach turned when the conditions of his contract were not met and he felt that he had been treated unfairly by his superiors. In a similar fashion, it was to King August II of Saxony that Bach dedicated his 1733 Missa (better known as the Kyrie and Gloria of the B minor mass) in the hope of receiving the title of Court Composer.
To point up the political and religious interconnections between Leipzig and Dresden, as well as between Pietism and Orthodoxy, our narrative will focus on the part played in Leipzig’s pietistic movement by two theologians: Johann Benedict Carpzov and Johannes Olearius. Carpzov was a prominent figure in the movement’s early stage, Olearius in a later one. Each was a professor of theology at the University, and each was a member of a prominent family of theologians and pastors with close ties to the nearby cities of Dresden and Halle. But, as we will see, in one case initial support of Spener’s “reform” movement turned to hostility, while in the other support continued unabated. In the second case, we also can establish a direct link between Spener’s supporters and J. S. Bach.
Johann Carpzov, a classmate and frequent correspondent of Spener, welcomed the publication of Pia Desideria in 1675, with its call for a renewed emphasis on personal piety. From the pulpit of the Thomaskirche, where he, like his father before him, served as a pastor, Carpzov urged his listeners to follow the precepts laid down by Spener. Furthermore, following the model of the conventicles which he and Spener had attended together as students in Strasbourg, he founded a society for Bible study. The group was called the Collegium Philobiblicum. Primarily scholarly in nature, it originally included only university students and was conducted in Latin.
Among its first members was August Hermann Francke, who faithfully attended the group’s meetings until the fall of 1687, when he left to study in northern Germany. It was there, in Lüneburg, that he had his famous “conversion experience.” After returning to Leipzig two years later and receiving an MA degree, Francke began giving lectures on Paul’s letters to the Ephesians and the Corinthians. Breaking with official university policy, he began to deliver his lectures in German, rather than Latin. Within a few months, they attracted a crowd of 300, including both students and townspeople. Because his overwhelming success provoked unease in Dresden, its council requested an account of Francke’s activities from the Leipzig authorities.
Of primary concern to the Saxon court was whether the followers of Francke could be regarded as members of a sect. Foremost in the council’s mind was the danger of social unrest caused by a “subversive” group, whether political or religious. Because the turmoil in Leipzig came soon after the primarily religious Thirty Years War had devastated Europe, the dangers the Elector and his advisors envisioned were mainly territorial. The Saxon Elector was one of the few who had signed the Augsburg Confession, thereby declaring that he and the State he ruled would become Protestant. Any sign of internal discord in Saxony would give his fellow Electors, the majority of whom had remained Catholic, an opportunity to intervene, seize power, and restore ties to the Papacy. Thus, Francke’s reforms were viewed by Dresden less in religious than in political terms.
The Francke Controversy
When the controversy over Francke’s teachings began, Dresden was sympathetic to Pietism. The court’s two leading theologians, both members of its council, were the Superintendent, Samuel Benedict Carpzov, the younger brother of Johann Benedict, and the court preacher, Philipp Spener. Spener’s success in Frankfurt as a pastor and leader of the Collegia Pietatis brought him to the attention of the religious leaders at the court. Among them were several nobility who supported Pietism, including the grandparents of Count Zinzendorf who later founded the Moravian church. In 1686, this group, far more receptive to Pietism than most of their counterparts in other parts of Germany, convinced Spener to leave Frankfurt and take up Protestant Germany’s most prestigious position at the time, pastor and court preacher to the Saxon Elector, Johann Georg III.
In Leipzig, the University leaders were also pro-Spener. The University’s Rector, Adam Rechenberg, Spener’s son-in-law, had only recently been elected to the position over Johann Carpzov. Rechenberg and the theological faculty assured the council in Dresden that the group of Pietistic students surrounding Francke did not constitute a sect and that, furthermore, there was nothing heretical about Francke’s teachings. The matter would have ended there were it not for Francke’s response to Dresden in the form of an “Apologia.” In addition to defending himself against what he perceived as an attack on his Lutheran Orthodoxy, he leveled a series of accusations against members of the theological faculty, Carpzov in particular. Furthermore, Francke strongly criticized the theological training at the University. He felt that far too much emphasis was placed on systematic theology, and not enough on scriptural exegesis. As a result, he complained, students rarely read the Bible, only commentaries. More inflammatory was a second letter written by Christian Thomasius, a law student, who later would become a member of Francke’s faculty at the University of Halle. Known in Leipzig for his anti-establishment views, including his demand to replace Latin with German and his opposition to Aristotelian scholasticism, Thomasius’s support undermined rather than strengthened Francke’s position at the University.
Although Rechenberg continued to view the controversy as a primarily academic matter, Johann Carpzov seized the occasion to sever his ties with Spener and to launch a series of attacks on the Pietistic movement. He delivered one attack from the pulpit of the Thomaskirche in a funeral sermon for a university student who had been a Pietist. Reacting to the funeral sermon, Joachim Feller, a professor of poetry at the university, wrote a sonnet in which he claimed pride in the designation “Pietist.” This was the first time this word was used in print to describe a follower of Spener. Carpzov was also connected with the publication of a book, printed anonymously, that accused Pietists of setting a fire to a village church on Christmas eve.
In seeking the support of the Dresden council in his crusade against Pietism, Carpzov turned to his brother Samuel for assistance. Together they convinced the Saxon authorities that Leipzigs growing number of conventicles should be forbidden and that students who declared themselves Pietists should not receive a stipend to attend the University. An edict to this effect was issued in 1690. At the same time, the council outlawed the publication of any books that mentioned Pietism, either attacking or defending it. Intended to prevent an acrimonious debate such as the one then taking place in Hamburg, the council’s action was seen by the Orthodox faculty at the Wittenberg and Rostock Universities as designed to protect the Pietists. But, despite the objections of the faculties and of the Carpzovs, the Elector allowed the ruling to stand. Martin Brecht sums up the first stage of the Pietistic movement in Leipzig in the first volume of a new series entitled The History of Pietism, with the observation: “In Leipzig, the formal organization of Pietism as a separate organization was forbidden, but no judgment was made against it.”
However, the ruling marked the end of Spener’s influence in Saxony, at least in an official capacity. He became increasingly isolated from the court partly because of a letter he wrote to the Elector imploring him to change his dissolute ways. After Spener resigned to take up a new position in Berlin, the post of court preacher was given to Samuel Carpzov. But the court’s hostility to Pietism abated in the early eighteenth century and, in 1724, an associate of August Francke was appointed court preacher. In Leipzig, the anti-Pietistic period ushered in by Carpzov’s attack on Francke lasted for a decade, from 1690 to 1700. Then, as in Dresden, the tide turned.
The Olearius Family
Johannes Olearius, the second theologian mentioned above, was primarily responsible for the change in Leipzig’s theological climate. He was the only member of the theological faculty who had continued to support Spener after the Francke controversy. When Johann Carpzov and his Orthodox colleague, Valentin Alberti, died within a few months of one another in 1699, Olearius assumed a more prominent role. Furthermore, the appointment of Adam Rechenberg, son-in-law of Spener and former University Rector, to replace Carpzov, dramatically altered the balance of power within the theological faculty. For the first time in several decades, a majority was sympathetic to Pietism. Olearius was their spokesperson.
Like the Carpzovs, the Olearius family had established and maintained close ties with Spener. The father of Leipzig theologian Johannes Olearius had been a fellow student of Spener in Strasbourg. As Superintendent in Halle, Olearius’ father had advised Spener to concentrate his reform efforts on the Free Cities of Germany, with their tradition of religious freedom and tolerance. We know that Spener heeded his advice from our earlier encounter with Bach in cities such as Lübeck and Mühlhausen.
Two other members of the Olearius family also deserve our attention. Both have links to Bach. Johann Gottfried Olearius, a brother of Johannes, was Superintendent in Arnstadt during the time that Bach was organist there. Through him, Bach was introduced to a devotional book titled The Christian’s Prayer Book (Christliche Bett-Schule), written by an uncle of the two brothers, also named Johannes. As we pointed out in Part Four of this series, Bach drew the text for his first cantata, “God’s Time is the Best Time” (Gottes Zeit ist die allerbeste Zeit) from this volume. And, as we will discover in the next part of this series, the elder Johannes Olearius, prolific writer of theological manuals concerned with the practice of Christian piety, is increasingly coming to be seen as an important source for the Leipzig cantata texts compiled by Bach and his librettists.
The Decades before Bach
Beginning in 1700, the younger Johannes Olearius, now the leading member of the theological faculty in Leipzig, took steps to redress the imbalance between Pietism and Orthodoxy that had resulted in the 1690s. As the final authority on what books would be sold in Leipzig, he approved the sale of a series of Pietistic books and pamphlets that included the writings of authors such as Gottfried Arnold and Conrad Dippel who were later regarded as separatists. Moreover, under Olearius’s leadership, the Leipzig faculty endorsed a publication whose author claimed that God’s grace to the “reborn” had “lasting effects.” Their endorsement was seen by both Pietists and Orthodox as a stamp of approval for the pietistic movement. The Wittenberg and Rostock faculties were still overwhelmingly Orthodox and they condemned the book. It implied, they argued, that no further repentance was needed for the “reborn.”
Additional signs of a new theological wind blowing in Leipzig can be seen in the following two events. First, in a formal document published in 1713, the theological faculty asserted that the term “Pietist” had been used to unjustly accuse devout believers of harmful acts against their neighbors and their God. Furthermore, the faculty went on to claim that Pietism was not a sect, and to label it such was “fictitious.” Although the faculty’s statement was in keeping with their initial response to the movement several decades earlier, it was a far cry from the assaults on Pietism by Johann Carpzov. Second, six years later in 1719, August Hermann Francke, who had been driven from the city 30 years earlier, was invited by the theological faculty to preach at the University church. This further illustrates how the religious establishment in Leipzig was, once again, receptive to Pietism, and it occurred only a few years before Bach arrived in the city.
By 1723, primarily due to the efforts of Olearius, Leipzig, more than any other major German city at the time, was in a position to provide Bach with a setting in which to write a “well-regulated church music.” By this I mean a music composed for a liturgical context, that encompassed both Pietistic themes and traditional Lutheran texts. We have seen how, up to this point in Bach’s life, religious and political circumstances hindered him from realizing his goal. Our task, in the next installment, is to examine to what extent a new theological environment will enable him to achieve it.
References
Brecht, Martin, ed. Der Pietismus vom siebzehnten bis zum frühen actzehnten Jahrhundert. Geschichte des Pietismus, Bd. I. (Pietism in the 17th and early 18th Centuries. vol. 1 of the series, History of Pietism), Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, 1993
Leube, Hans. Die Geschichte der pietistische Bewegung in Leipzig, in Orthodoxie und Pietismus, Luther-Verlag, Bielefeld (1975) 153-267. (Reprint of a 1921 dissertation based on the archives housed in Dresden.)
