“When they Ask”
Excerpts from an address delivered Covenant Founders’ Day Service, February 19, 1995, Bloomington Covenant Church, Bloomington, Minnesota
Theme One: Remembering
Gustav Niebuhr argues that society should grapple with how to remember events in history because “it is in the telling of their stories that people and nations come to understand themselves.”1 Tomorrow marks the 110th anniversary of the founding of the Svenska Evangeliska Missionsförbundet i America, The Swedish Evangelical Mission Covenant in America (now known simply as the Evangelical Covenant Church). Rev. Erik August Skogsbergh, the “Swedish Moody” and then pastor of the Tabernacle (now First Covenant) Church in Minneapolis, described Friday, February 20, 1885 as “probably the most important day in the history of the free Christian Mission Work in America.”
Skogsbergh’s optimism notwithstanding, for most members of our denomination, Covenant Founders’ Day has become a meaningless date in the church year. It has, for all purposes, been removed from the Covenants’ consciousness and forgotten! Of course, this kind of talk begs the question, Why are we here tonight? Should we be celebrating? What should we be celebrating? Does what we do here tonight have any significance? Are we a faithful remnant or are we fools? Are we caretakers of a priceless heritage, or are we dinosaurs who do not yet realize that we are headed for extinction?
As a denomination, we seem to have fulfilled the pessimistic observation of the Teacher who wrote, “The people of long ago are not remembered...” (Eccl. 1:11). There is bitter irony in the recognition of our denominational amnesia; we pride ourselves in being people of the Scriptures which provide numerous references to the importance of remembering and the consequences for not remembering. Does not the Bible present a history of a triune God and God’s people that emphasizes remembering who God is and what God has done; who we are and what God calls us to do and be?
Remembering forces us to think beyond ourselves and our present circumstances to a previous place or event or person. It forces us to contemplate; to ask questions; to reevaluate; to make connections. Remembering also requires some action on our part. It requires that we actively engage the past and come to grips with whatever lessons it imparts. We may be afraid of the past. We may be fascinated, revolted, haunted, saddened, or pleasantly surprised by the past. We may curse or praise the past; but we dare not forget it. Remember the words of the bard, William Shakespeare, in The Tempest, “What’s past is prologue;” or, if you prefer the words of the Teacher, “What has been is what will be” (Eccl. 1:9).
Theme Two: Heritage
In I Corinthians 4:7, the Apostle Paul strikes powerfully at our overwhelming human pride and arrogance—our hubris—with the simple query, “What do you have that you did not receive?” Your material wealth? Your cultural wealth? Your biological wealth (the gifts of air, water, land, and life)? Your family? Your education? Your freedom? Your friendships?
What do you have that you did not receive? Paul’s question also applies to our religious heritage, does it not? Allow me to illustrate this line of thought by briefly describing for you a few individuals in the religious pedigree I have reconstructed from Swedish church records and personal knowledge for the paternal side of my family:
| Per Persson, b. 1687, crofter | Godly |
| wife Karin Christophersdotter, b. 1697 | Godfearing |
| Pehr Olsson Borg, b. 1692, miner | Godfearing |
| Olof Thomsson, b. 1728, crofter | Pious |
| wife Elisabet Ersdotter, b. 1736 | Christlike |
| Matts Rosendahl, b. 1744, master blacksmith | Christlike |
| Olof Persson, b. 1781, charcoal maker | Pious |
John and Ida Erickson, Swedish immigrants; Mission Friends; charter members of the Swedish Mission (now Grace Covenant) Church, Stambaugh, MI; my great grandparents; Christians.
Rev. Fritz and Jennie Erickson, Lifelong Covenanters; my grandparents; Christians.
C. Eldred and Jennie Erickson, Livelong Covenanters; my parents; Christians.
I recognize, as did the Psalmist, that “I have a goodly heritage” (Ps. 16:6). To paraphrase a familiar song: “If it had not been for the Lord (and all these saints) on my side, tell me, where would I be?”2 I ask myself, Would I be a Christian? Would I be the person I am today, if it were not for the Christian witness of saints who preceded me?
And what about you? What do you have that you did not receive from your spiritual predecessors? While many of you have a Swedish and Covenant pedigree, many of you do not. Maybe yours is Anglican, Dutch Reformed, Irish Catholic, Scotch-Irish Presbyterian, or Methodist. Maybe you are descended from cultures and peoples indigenous to Central or South America, Africa, or Asia. Maybe you are a first-generation Christian. Regardless of the unique path that brought each of us to this moment in our spiritual pilgrimage, I want to argue that it is more than just O.K. for Christians to remember and celebrate their specific or collective spiritual heritage. I believe that it is also necessary, and that it is something God wants us to do.
Theme Three: Remembering Covenant Heritage
Our ostensible purpose for gathering here tonight is to commemorate the founding of the Evangelical Covenant Church. Some of you were born and raised in the Covenant; some of you may have been dragged into it (not kicking and screaming, I hope); and some of you may have chosen it voluntarily. Regardless of your method of entry, are you aware of the historical and spiritual heritage of the fellowship to which you belong? Unfortunately, its a story that many have either forgotten or have never heard. Sadly, its a story that many are unable or unwilling to tell. I consider it a privilege to be able to retell briefly the story as I understand it.
We are spiritual heirs of the Swedish immigrants who were known as Mission Friends (missionsvänner). These fellow believers were products of the pietistic revivals in Sweden. They had strong interests in home and foreign missions, and met informally in small fellowship groups called conventicles. They were further characterized by their love of singing and their emphasis on reading the Bible and religious literature. Thus, they were also known as readers (läsare).
Since the Mission Friends shared a common culture, language, and religion—they were Swedish and Lutheran—one might logically assume that they also had a natural affinity for one another. They did not! From the onset, they were divided on such contentious issues as the rightness of union (denominationalism vs. anti-denominationalism), baptism (infant or adult), clergy (ordained or lay), and views on eschatology and atonement. Ultimately, these issues precluded the Mission Friends from achieving a shared common vision for the church in America. The disparity within their ranks is reflected in the fact that, between 1872 and 1874, they organized three different synods as alternatives to the Augustana Lutheran synod.
Ministers and people, of the Mission and Ansgar Synods and a number of free and independent churches, gathered in Chicago February 18-25, 1885, to explore the possibilities of uniting. Sixty-five official delegates met to discuss these two questions: 1) “Is it right or wrong for Christian congregations and societies to unite for fellowship in the work of the Kingdom of God, and upon what basis can such a union take place?” and 2) “How shall we, in a Christian and practical way, achieve a brotherly union among our believing countrymen in America for the propagation of the Gospel and for a Christian congregational life?”
For two days they engaged in lively discussion and debate. It was a classic turf battle; reminiscent of contemporary mergers involving cities, school districts and corporate America. The delegates had vested interests in either their positions or their organizations. Would their position prevail? Would their synod persist or be dissolved? Where would they fit in the hierarchy of an entirely new organization? Although the initial behavior of the delegates would later be compared to “so many goats [trying] to budge each other,” E. A. Skogsbergh gives us the following eyewitness account of the final outcome of their deliberations:
Now a turn came in the affairs. All spoke in the same vein . . . they would be willing to work for an organization of a union of the churches. . . . A motion was made that all those in favor of an association should stand up and as far as I was able to determine, there was not one of the members of the meeting but that he stood up in joy and happiness. A brother led us in prayer while standing, after which the whole congregation enthusiastically joined in the singing of Luther’s mighty hymn, “A Mighty Fortress is our God.”
In the remaining days of the organizational meeting, the delegates adopted a constitution, elected an executive committee, made decisions on how this Covenant was to function with reference to ministers, and how it was to relate to other Christian denominations or churches. They also decided to send a missionary to New York City to minister to the physical and spiritual needs of Swedish immigrants arriving daily at Castle Garden. Above all, the Covenant founders delineated a vision for the church that, according to Glenn Anderson, late dean of North Park Theological Seminary, was characterized by four facets of faith: “the authority of the Word of God, the necessity of new life in Christ, the ideal of the believer’s church, and the importance of spiritual and theological freedom.”
Brothers and sisters, the legacy we have inherited is simple, yet profound! Unique, yet fragile! Defining, yet nebulous! Parochial, yet universal! It is within this aggregate of faith statements that one begins to discover and understand the uniqueness, or as Karl Olsson described it, “the mystique,” of the Covenant Church.3
Theme Four: When They Ask
Newsweek magazine recently featured a series of articles under the title “The Search for the Sacred: America’s Quest for Spiritual Meaning.” The authors of one article noted that as we approach the year 2000—the millennium—American behavior will be characterized by increased spiritual seeking and soul-searching. They concluded:
‘People feel they want something they’ve lost, and they don’t remember what it is they’ve lost. But it has left a gaping hole.’ That, in essence, is the seeker’s quest: to fill the hole with a new source of meaning. Why are we here? What is the purpose of our existence? The answers change in each generation, but the questions are eternal.4
Although I like Newsweek magazine, I cannot and do not accept the premise that the answers to questions relating to ultimate existence and purpose “change in each generation.” What a frightening thought! It is a notion contrary to the foundations of the Christian faith, which are grounded in two very fundamental truths. First, that God doesn’t change (Mal. 3:6); and, second, that the Word of God doesn’t change (I Pet. 1:25).
The Old Testament text (Josh. 4:1-7) assigned for this day provides interesting insight pertaining to the question: “Why are we here?” both tonight and in a more ultimate sense. It is the story of the miraculous crossing by nation of Israel of the Jordan River into the land of Canaan, the promised land. The lessons to be drawn from this text are numerous. I would like to focus on just one aspect of the story—the stone memorial. Imagine, if you will, a memorial built with twelve large stones taken from the bottom of a river. I can tell you from personal experience that such stones are typically encrusted with calcium carbonate deposits; crawling with myriad worms and insect larvae; festooned with filamentous algae; and topped off with a gelatinous mass of fish eggs. In my mind’s eye, this memorial is not a pretty sight! But the fact that God ordered its construction to commemorate Israel’s crossing of the Jordan River implies that it may have great significance for us. In this regard, let me raise several thoughts.
First of all, one can infer from the text that God wants God’s people to remember the wondrous deeds done by God on their behalf. Second, that without some kind of memorial to help us remember, we are prone to forget God’s past works. Third, that such a memorial will invoke inquiry from future generations. Verse 6 states, “In the future, when your children ask you (italics mine), ‘What do these stones mean?’” Likewise, verse 21 states, “In the future, when your descendants ask their fathers (italics mine), ‘What do these stones mean?’” Notice the text does not say “If your children ask you,” or “In case your children ask you,” or “In the event that your children ask you.” It says, “When [they] ask!” The obvious implication for us is that we must expect and anticipate the questions of future generations and we must be ready to provide meaningful answers to them.
Last, and most important, this memorial points beyond itself to a God who acts in history. God made it possible for the nation of Israel to cross the Jordan “so that all the peoples of the earth might know that the hand of the Lord is powerful, and so that you might always fear the Lord your God” (Josh. 4:24). That is why we are here. The purpose of our celebration tonight and of our very existence is to remember what God has done—whether it be God’s involvement in the spectacular passage of a nation across a flooded river or in the more mundane founding of a Covenant by a handful of devout Swedish immigrants—and to show reverence toward God.
Theme Five: Beyond Remembrance
One of the great paradoxes woven through the very fabric of the Creation is that all living organisms exhibit striking unity at the molecular, cellular, organismic, and populational levels of organization, while they simultaneously exhibit tremendous diversity. Biologists now estimate that the Earth contains over 30 million different species.5 The Psalmist said it best: “O Lord, how manifold (i.e. diverse) are your works! In wisdom you have made them all” (Ps. 104:24).
In similar fashion, the theme of unity and diversity runs through the Christian church. Christians are united in the sovereign God they worship, the Christ they confess as Lord and Savior, and the Holy Spirit that dwells within them. Yet, Christians also exhibit diversity that manifests itself along geographical, cultural, theological, and, ultimately, denominational lines.
The theme of unity and diversity has also been part of the Covenant since its inception. At the organizational meeting in 1885, F. M. Johnson preached a sermon based on the familiar Ps. 119:63 text: “I am a companion of all who fear you, of those who keep your precepts.” Did you know that his sermon addressed the similarities and differences among Christians and that he concluded that the similarities absorbed the differences? This seems to be an appropriate time to consider whether we have remembered Johnson’s take-home lesson.
The Covenant’s growth and development over the last 110 years has been accompanied by tremendous change, which is both natural and inevitable. We began as a diverse (although ethnically homogeneous) group of Swedish Mission Friends, united by a common vision for Christ’s church. We continue today as a much more diverse group of believers—less Swedish, less Lutheran, and less traditional to be sure—but also, I think, less focused and less united. Is it possible that diversity within the Covenant, which is most noticeable in our disparate worship styles, has absorbed our unity? Has the religious and theological freedom we as Covenanters value so highly been replaced with a form of religious and theological anarchy? If so, what are the long-term consequences of this trend, especially as it relates to liturgical diversity, for our denomination?
An insight gained from the study of tropical forests might help us answer this question. Tropical forests, the most diverse ecosystems on this planet, are estimated to contain 50 to 75% of all living species.6 Yet biologists have been surprised to learn that this diversity has not produced stability—these forests are very fragile and easily disrupted and destroyed. They are generally considered the most endangered ecosystems on Earth. The new conventional wisdom from the tropics is that environmental stability produces diversity. This suggests to me that our continued success as a denomination will not necessarily be guaranteed by the illusion of stability that comes with growth and diversification. It will be assured only if we remember our core—that which provides the stability. And what is our core, our cohering principle? The founders called it a förbund—a Covenant or fellowship of believers. They founded a family in the faith, which was guided by the Word of God and united by the Lamb of God.
There are those within our denomination, quite possibly a majority, who would argue that we have outgrown our need for Covenant Founders’ Day. To them I would simply say, “Wake up and smell the egg coffee!” In the final analysis, Covenant Founders’ Day is not about the past, or old Swedish pietists, or long-departed Mission Friends, or Nils Frykman hymns. (As much as it pains me to say that!) This day is important and necessary because it forces us beyond such mere remembrance. This day is about the present and it is about us; it is about the future and it is about our children! It is a celebration, as well as a reminder, of the fundamental truth that “the song goes on” only if we “take up the strain” and become part of the legacy by daily living and sharing that which we have received.
Let us pray:
Oh God, You have given us the heritage of those who fear your name. Keep us ever mindful of our awesome responsibility as the current stewards of both the broader Christian legacy and the more specific Covenant legacy. Grant each of us the wisdom to remember, to appreciate, and to understand the full import of that which we have inherited! And in the language of our founders we would also say:
Gud, vår Gud, till dig vi se, Giv oss rik välsignelse;
Låt ditt evangelium Ljuda klart på alla rum!
7
Lord, our God, we seek Thy face,
Bless us with Thy saving grace,
May Thy heralds ev’rywhere
Fervently Thy truth declare.
1. Niebuhr, “Common past, different perspectives,” 4A. ↩︎
2. See “If It Had Not Been for the Lord,” by Margaret Pleasant Douroux, in The Song Goes On (Chicago: Covenant Publications, 1990), 131. ↩︎
3. See Karl A. Olsson, By One Spirit (Chicago: Covenant Press, 1962); A Family of Faith (Chicago: Covenant Press, 1975); Into One Body (Chicago: Covenant Press, 1985). ↩︎
4. Barbara Kantrowitz et al., “In Search of the Sacred,” Newsweek, 28 November 1994, 55. ↩︎
5. Robert M. May, “How Many Species Inhabit the Earth?,” Scientific American, October 1992, 42-48; Edward O. Wilson, The Diversity of Life (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992). ↩︎
6. Judith Gradwohl and Russell Greenberg, Saving The Tropical Forests (Covelo, CA: Island Press, 1988), 25-51; G. Tyler Miller, Jr., Living In The Environment (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Co., 1994), 263-281; Edward O. Wilson, ed., Biodiversity (Washington, D. C.: National Academy Press, 1988); Edward O. Wilson, “Threats to Biodiversity,” Scientific American, September 1989, 108-116; Edward O. Wilson, The Diversity of Life (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992). ↩︎
7. Verse 3 of “Sabbath Day of Rest and Cheer,” by Joel Blomqvist, in The Hymnal of the Evangelical Covenant Church of America (Chicago: Covenant Press, 1950), 20. ↩︎
