Pietism and the Modern Church
Beginning in the latter half of the 17th century and continuing throughout most of the 18th century, two movements emerged which were to play an important role in giving shape to what has come to be known as modern Western society. Rationalism was essentially an intellectual movement which laid the theoretical foundations on which the structures of modern Western society were built. Pietism was essentially a religious movement which made important contributions to shaping the consciousness of the church, particularly of the Protestant churches, in the modern West.
In one sense, each of these movements was a reaction against the period of theological orthodoxy that followed the Reformation. There were many people in Western society who believed that the religious fervor which had animated the great movements of reform in the 16th century had been lost. They thought that theologians had fastened onto the churches a sterile orthodoxy that emphasized the holding of correct doctrines rather than the living out of a vital faith. We know now that this was to misinterpret the intentions of the orthodox theologians, but it was a view of orthodoxy that was widely held in the 17th and 18th centuries.
In a more positive sense, the movements of Rationalism and Pietism were attempts to recover certain emphases of the Western tradition that the period of orthodoxy had minimized. Thus, for example, Rationalism recovered, among other things, the Renaissance emphasis upon the dignity of human beings—a conception that had almost disappeared in some Protestant conceptions of the worthlessness of humans. And whereas Orthodoxy said that a Christian is one who agrees with certain theological propositions and participates in formal patterns of worship, Pietism insisted that a Christian is one who experiences a personal relationship with God and makes a conscious commitment to Jesus Christ.
Let us turn now to look a bit more closely at the Pietist movements.
The Nature of Pietism
Pietism as an historical movement originated in both Lutheran and Reformed churches in the late 17th century and was given powerful expression on the continent and in England during the 18th century. It was brought to America where it played a dominant role in the formation of American Protestantism.
What was Pietism? We have already suggested that initially it was, at least in part, a reaction against Protestant orthodoxy. Its participants believed that the Protestant churches had become stranded on the shoals of dogmatism, institutionalism, and polemics. Pietism believed that Protestant orthodoxy had formalized religion and created a situation in which it was almost impossible to nurture and express a vibrant Christian faith and life. Pietism insisted on the need for recovering the personal dimension of Christian life, and it maintained that this could be achieved through the personal experience of spiritual rebirth. Pietism, then, was a movement within the churches which hoped to bring about the renewal of Christian life by focusing upon the necessity for personal religious experience.
Out of this central concern there emerged the particular emphases of Pietism: (1) Its stress on human “lostness” prior to personal rebirth; (2) its insistence on the necessity for conversion as a self-conscious experience; (3) its view of the radical character of conversion often described as a passing from death to life; (4) its emphasis on human decision and commitment of life as the decisive factor in the conversion experience; and (5) its insistence that conversion must result in the living of a new kind of life. Usually the “new life” was defined in terms of avoiding vices and achieving certain virtues. The persistent temptation for the Pietist, therefore, was to revert to a legalistic conception of the Christian life. In terms of one’s own moralistic standards, one could press on to perfection; at the same time, one often felt himself or herself entitled to stand in judgment of an “unrighteous” neighbor.
Some Consequences
In its attempts to reemphasize the personal element in religion as over against the orthodox tendency to formalize religion, Pietism usually gave expression to a spirit of individualism. As it is used here, the word “individualism” refers to the view of human life which gives significance to the individual person only when he or she is seen in relative isolation from the community rather than when he or she is seen as part of the community. In other words, Pietism tended to equate the “personal” with the “individual.” And this had at least two important consequences.
First of all, it led to a particular view of the nature of the church. For the Pietist, the true church is made up only of those individuals who have had the experience of rebirth. By their own voluntary decision they join themselves together to form a church. The church does not exist prior to its individual members; individuals exist prior to the church. By their own individual consent they create the church; apart from that consent there is no church. By contrast, the reformers had insisted that the church exists where the Word is proclaimed and the Sacraments are administered. They believed that the decisive element in constituting the church, without which in fact there can be no church, is the presence of Christ as made known in Word and Sacrament. The Pietists understood the decisive and constitutive element of the church to be the voluntary consent of its individual members.
In the second place, pietistic individualism led to a particular view of the relation of the Christian man or woman to society. It tended to identify society with “the world.” Because “the world,” in its view, is evil, the Christian must withdraw himself or herself from it. By this, Pietism meant primarily that the “structures” of society (e.g., political and economic structures) are evil. Hence, the Christian person, as a Christian, ought to participate in them as little as is humanly possible. One’s involvement in society should be expressed by relieving the distress of one’s suffering neighbor (i.e., by offering “charity”), not by seeking to change the social structures that produce distress (i.e., by working for “justice”). Pietism produced magnificent works of charity, but it steered clear of direct social action.
The Influence of Pietism
Pietism has had widespread influence in the modern church and that in at least two senses.
In the first place, its influence has been widespread in extent. To a greater or lesser degree, the Pietist movement penetrated nearly all of the major Protestant churches. The Lutheran churches were greatly affected by the Pietist movement, which centered at the University of Halle in Germany. Here Jacob Spener, oftentimes regarded as the father of modern Pietism, and A. H. Franke did their important work. German Pietism also was advanced through the work of Count von Zinzendorf and the Moravians. Pietism was carried into the Lutheran churches in Scandinavia through the efforts of a number of people, particularly lay preachers like Hans Nielsen Hauge in Norway and C. O Rosenius in Sweden. The Reformed churches were influenced by Pietist conventicles that flourished in Germany and the Netherlands. And in England, the spirit of Pietism manifested itself both in the great evangelical revival of the 18th century and in the so-called Wesleyan revivals under the leadership of John and Charles Wesley. The latter led eventually to the formation of the Methodist Church. In America, almost all churches were influenced by the Pietism that was carried to the common people in a succession of great revival movements. When the population moved westward, circuit riders and revivalists brought a religion to people that was permeated by pietistic evangelism and this gave birth to revivalism as a technique.
But, not only has the influence of Pietism been widespread in extent, it has also to a large degree formed and shaped the character and consciousness of the modern church. The patterns established by Pietism (e.g., its conception of the church and its view of the relation of church to society) have been indelibly stamped upon the churches. Thus the churches, particularly Protestant churches in America, have reflected both the strengths and the weaknesses of Pietism. Somehow they must come to terms with this heritage as they seek to minister to the 20th [and now to the 21st] century.
