Pietisten

Vol. X, No. 2 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Summer 1995

J. S. Bach and Pietism

J. S. Bach in Cöthen: Capellmeister to a Reformed Court

(Sixth in a series)

by Don O Franklin

In the last installment we saw how, in the cantatas and organ works Bach wrote in Weimar, he was able to achieve his goal of a “well-regulated church music.” (I use the term, as defined earlier in the series, to refer to a church music intended for liturgical use, but infused with the spirit of Pietism.) We left off our account in 1716 when Bach abruptly ceased to compose cantatas for the court chapel on a regular basis. By August of the following year he had accepted a position in Cöthen, where he would serve as Capellmeister to a Prince who was a member of the Reformed Church.

This installment begins with a brief description of the relationship of the Reformed church to both Lutheran Orthodoxy and Pietism followed by a close look at the conditions under which Bach left Weimar. Turning to Cöthen, a duchy in Anhalt, we survey Bach’s life at a court where he would, for the first and only time in his career, compose no music for the church service nor have a full-scale organ at his disposal. Furthermore, as a Lutheran, he would be a member or a religious minority. Anhalt, which originally followed Luther’s teachings, and whose prince signed the Augsburg confession, adopted the Reformed faith in 1597.

The Reformed Church in Germany

For several decades after the Reformation, the practices, and even doctrines, of Luther’s followers varied from region to region. Although the Augsburg Confession of 1530 set forth the principles of the Protestant faith, it was not until 1577 when the Formula of Concord was drawn up, that a doctrinal basis for a unified church was firmly established. But even though it codified doctrinal matters, the Formula of Concord proved to be a divisive document for German Protestants. Those who signed the Concord became known as “Lutherans,” a term that before this time was used derisively by Catholics to refer to the followers of a man, rather than the teachings of the historical church. Protestants who refused to sign the document took the name of “Reformed.”

Viewing themselves as strict adherents of the “reforms” of Luther, the Reformed found several aspects of the Concord reminiscent of papal practices. They strongly objected, for example, to exorcism, the rite of removing the devil from a child at baptism, a practice that Luther retained (later it was rejected by the Pietists). Furthermore, the Reformed saw both baptism and communion as primarily symbolic or representative acts. To underline this point, they substituted communion tables for altars and removed all icons and images from their churches. In addition, they adopted a less liturgical order of service than the Lutherans and singing was limited to the singing of psalms, usually without organ accompaniment. The doctrine and practice of the Reformed church in Germany did not conform to Lutheranism, nor did it, like its European counterparts in Switzerland and Holland, strictly adhere to all of Calvin’s teachings.

The Formula of Concord was written two decades after the Peace of Augsburg and provided religious autonomy for each German state. According to the principle of cuius regio, eius religio—whose the rule, his the religion—the ruler of each state determined its religion. Those states that did not sign the Concord, therefore, became Reformed. The freedom of worship of a Lutheran minority—whether Orthodox or Pietist—depended on the toleration policy of the prince. As we saw in the previous article, Brandenburg was one of the most tolerant Reformed lands. Because its rulers allowed, and even encouraged, religious diversity, Brandenburg became a haven for Pietists at the end of the seventeenth century. In 1691, Philipp Spener was invited there, specifically to Berlin, when the Orthodox Elector of Saxony could no longer tolerate Spener’s sermons against the excesses of the Dresden court. And, it was Elector Frederick Wilhelm of Brandenburg who appointed August Francke professor in Halle.1

Bach Chronology

1685 Born March 21 in Eisenach, Germany
1700 Choral scholarship at Lüneburg
1703-07 Organist at the Neukirche in Arnstadt
1705 Four month visit to Lübeck
Apprenticeship with Buxetehude
1707 Married Maria Barbara
1707-08 Organist at Mühlhausen
1708-17 Organist at Weimar
1717-23 Capellmeister at Cöthen
1720 Death of Maria Barbara
1721 Married Anna Magdalena Wülken
1723-50 Cantor and music director
at Thomaskirche, Leipzig
1750 Died July 28 in Leipzig

Reformed Prince and Pietist mother: Links to Weimar

By 1716, the pious and peaceful Lutheran court in Weimar that Bach happily joined in 1709 was to become hostile and fractured. Weimar was located in Thuringia, which became almost exclusively Lutheran after the Reformation. Primarily because Thuringia’s foremost rulers, such as Ernest the Pious, had tolerated a wide range of practices within the Lutheran church, few Reformed or other churches were established. Ernst’s descendents, however, were not always as tolerant or conciliatory. Duke Wilhelm of Weimar, childless and married to a Lutheran princess, ruled co-jointly with his younger brother Johann. Johann, in turn, was married to a princess from Zerbst, the only court in Anhalt to have returned to Lutheranism in the late seventeenth century, and, in addition, to have become Pietistic. When the brothers’ joint rule came to an end in 1704 with Johann’s death, his eldest son, Ernst, even after he became of age, was forced to remain under the rule of his uncle. But when Ernst, like his Father, married a princess from Anhalt, the underlying tension between the families erupted.

In this case, the princess was Eleanora of Cöthen, the daughter of a Reformed father and a Lutheran mother with pietist leanings. In 1692, Emmanuel, Eleanora’s father, had married a Lutheran noblewoman, Gisela Agnes van Rath. Princess Gisela quickly became an advocate of the Lutheran faith. In 1693, immediately following her marriage, she achieved full legal status for the Lutherans who previously had not been eligible to apply for positions at the court and who had to send their children to schools in nearby Brandenburg. The following year, she laid the cornerstone for a Lutheran church and, in 1711, founded a religious community of Lutheran noblewomen who were influential in introducing Pietism to Cöthen. When her husband died in 1704, Princess Gisela assumed power until their son, Leopold, came of age in 1715. During her regency, she continued to nurture a climate of toleration, always careful to keep a delicate balance between the public religion of the court, which was Reformed, and her own personal religious practices.

On January 24, 1716, the marriage of Eleanora and Duke Ernst took place at Gisela’s estate, presumably conducted by a Lutheran pastor of her choice. As a member of the Weimar court, Bach also was in attendance. His meeting with Prince Leopold, his sister, Eleanora, and their mother was to mark the beginning of a long association. It also appears to have had a dramatic effect on his career, for within a short time he had stopped composing cantatas for the court chapel, and the following year would take up his position in Cöthen.

Soon after the marriage, Duke Wilhelm of Weimar threatened the members of his court with fines if they had any association with the household of his nephew Ernst. In light of his earlier associations with both the young Duke Wilhelm and his brother, Johann Ernst, whom Bach had taught composition and keyboard lessons, it is understandable that Bach became closely affiliated with the “new regime.” The dissension that subsequently arose between Bach and Wilhelm may explain why Bach, who had composed a cantata per month before the January wedding, composed no new works between February and September of that year. It may also be the reason why Wilhelm, when the position of Capellmeister became free in December of 1716, looked outside of Weimar for a new court music director. It is true that Georg Philipp Telemann, with whom the Duke made contact, was more renowned throughout Germany, but Wilhelm may have bypassed Bach because he feared that Bach would have the political and religious interests of Wilhelm’s nephew and new wife at heart. Furthermore, when Bach accepted the Cöthen appointment the following August, Wilhelm allowed him to leave Weimar only after he had served six weeks of house imprisonment.

Bach as Capellmeister at Cöthen

At the time of Bach, Cöthen was a provincial court, small and relatively remote, but with musical, as well as political and religious, ties to Berlin. Situated in a more rural setting than Weimar, the castle was surrounded at that time by a moat and lavish gardens.2

Bach clearly relished the rich musical life available at the court and the collegial and harmonious relationship he enjoyed with Leopold. When he wrote to his childhood friend Georg Erdmann in 1730, Bach summed up his time in Cöthen as follows: “There I had a gracious Prince, who both loved and knew music, and in his service I intended to spend the rest of my life.” Bach’s resources included a gifted group of instrumentalists along with a fine collection of instruments and the ability to bring guest soloists to the court frequently.

During his nearly six years in Cöthen (December, 1717 to April, 1723), Bach wrote most of the instrumental works that we hear performed in today’s concert halls: The Brandenburg Concertos, the violin concertos, the unaccompanied pieces for violin and cello, the major portion of the keyboard suites, and Book I of the Well-tempered Clavier, a collection of 24 preludes and fugues. In contrast, his few choral scores were limited to secular pieces, primarily birthday and New Year’s Day cantatas, and are all but unknown to us today. The scores for these works were either lost or discarded when Bach incorporated portions of them into his Leipzig cantatas.

When Bach arrived at the court, relations between Reformed and Lutheran were friendly. There was an intermingling of the two confessions rare for the time. When a son was born to Bach and his wife in 1718, the child, named Leopold, was baptized at the court chapel. The child’s godparents included Eleanora, the Prince, and other members of the court, all affiliated with the Reformed Church. Bach, in turn, served as godparent at baptisms that took place both at the court chapel and the Lutheran church— the Agnuskirche, where Gisela, its patroness, continued to be active. The Agnuskirche’s records show that Bach received communion regularly there between 1719 and 1723, and he may have composed a cantata for the Dedication Festival of the church in 1719. If so, it would have been the single liturgical work that he wrote while in Cöthen.

This idyllic period in Bach’s life seems to have come to an end in 1720. That year, a new superintendent was appointed to the court who would soon alter the relations between the two confessions. The same year, Bach’s wife of 12 years, Maria Barbara, died while he was accompanying the Prince on a trip to Carlsbad. When Bach arrived home, she had been buried and he was left with four surviving children, the oldest of whom was 11.

Visit to Hamburg

Although we cannot document the purpose of Bach’s visit to Hamburg in the fall of 1720, we know that it included a visit to Adam Reincken, organist of the Catharinekirche. As was the local practice, Bach, after the Saturday vespers service, improvised for over a half an hour on the chorale melody “By the waters of Babylon.” When he had finished playing, Reincken, then 97 years old, is reported to have said, “I thought the art of improvising was dead, but I see that it lives on in you.”

While (and perhaps because) Bach was in the city, his name was put on a list of eight candidates for the organ position at the neighboring Jacobikirche.3 He had to return to Cöthen and the service of the Prince, so Bach did not remain in Hamburg. But church records show that the committee actively pursued him and held the position open until they received word that he was not interested. It has been thought that Bach did not apply for the position because, by tradition, a new organist was expected to make a substantial donation to the church’s coffers. This interpretation is based on an anecdote related in a 1728 publication by the theorist and composer Johann Mattheson (neither the pastor nor the organist is mentioned by name); “The eloquent chief preacher. . . closed his sermon [during the following Christmas season] with something like the following pronouncement: ‘I am firmly convinced that even if one of the angels of Bethlehem who played divinely came down from heaven and wished to become organist of the Jacobikirche, if he had no money, he might just as well fly away again.’”

Consistent with the new perspective from which we are examining Bach’s life in this series, I propose that there was another reason why Bach did not apply for the organist position: namely, the rigid theological stance of the church’s pastor, Erdmann Neumeister. On his way to Hamburg, Bach may have expected to encounter the poet whose cantata texts he had set in Weimar a few years earlier. The young Neumeister, while Orthodox, had been sympathetic to the Pietist movement. His earlier connection to Pietism, as Wolfgang Miersemann points out in a recent study, is evident in a communion book published in 1703 titled “Approach to the Throne of Grace.” On arriving in Hamburg, Bach found, instead, a polemicist and anti-pietist, whose writings now consisted of diatribes against both Pietist and Reformed. By calling into question the doctrinal basis of Pietism, coupled with vicious attacks on Spener, Neumeister and his fellow Hamburg pastor, Johann Friedrich Mayer, had polarized the relations between Orthodox and Pietist within the Lutheran church in northern Germany. As we have seen, Bach avoided such hostile environments in the past, and I suggest that he did so once again.

Confessional Conflict in Cöthen

A year after Bach returned to the court, Leopold married Princess Friderica from Bernburg, another duchy in Anhalt. Because Bach refers to the Princess as “unmusical” in the Erdmann letter cited above, this event has been heralded by historians as the impetus for Bach leaving the court two years later. However, recent research suggests that it played a less important role in his decision than the change in religious atmosphere that took place at the court between 1721 and 1723.

In a 1979 article in the Bach-Jahrbuch, Herbert Zimpel documents the extent of the confessional conflict that took place in Cöthen in 1722 and 1723, and describes how Leopold, with the assistance and, likely, the initiative of the new Superintendent, set out to undo the policies established by Gisela. Leopold undertook this project, Zimpel suggests, to assert himself against his mother, to be his “own man.” However, Zimpel does not take into account the role of the Prince’s new wife, Friederica, who, like her husband, (but unlike her mother-in-law) was Reformed. As had happened earlier in Weimar, it is more likely that the shift in the balance of power and the ensuing conflict was the result of the arrival at the court of a new princess.

Also, left out of Zimpel’s discussion to date is the “spiritual awakening” that Princess Gisela experienced in 1721. First pointed out in a doctoral dissertation in the 1920s, it has again come to light in a collection of documents on Zinzendorf and other “pietistic nobility” that was published in 1975. We know of the awakening through the correspondence of one of her fellow noblewomen. And when Auguste Francke visited Gisela at her estate in Nienburg, where she had retired after Leopold assumed power, he rejoiced in “her heartfelt desire for a nearer relationship with God.” The same year, 1722, the princess and her fellow Lutherans filed a formal petition against the Reformed court. They complained not only about the additional fees charged to be married and baptized by a Lutheran pastor, but also of the increasing difficulty they experienced in educating their children in the Lutheran religion, including the court’s diminished support for a new school building. Described in today’s terms, the complaint cited 16 cases of harassment and discrimination.

One of its signers was Georg Friderich Zeideler, who had served since 1719 as Deacon of the Agnuskirche, and who, as a member of Gisela’s party, was clearly sympathetic to Pietism. I mention him here because we believe he conducted the marriage of Bach to his second wife, Anna Magdalena, in December of 1721. That Zeideler officiated at the wedding is another indication that Bach did not, as most writers have claimed, avoid the presence of pietistic clergy within the Lutheran church.

It is within this context that we look at the three often-cited titles that Bach wrote on the cover page of the Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach that he copied out for his new wife in 1722: Anti-Melancholicus (“Against Melancholy”), Evangelische Christen-Schule (“Evangelical Christian Instruction”), and Anti-Calvinismus (“Against Calvinism”). All three titles were included in the inventory of Bach’s theological library drawn up after his death. All three were the work of August Pfeiffer, who published the first two volumes while a professor of theology at the University of Leipzig in the 1680s. The third appeared in the following decade when Pfeiffer served as superintendent in Lübeck. This was during the time of Buxtehude and slightly before Bach’s visit to the city.

The first volume is a devotional work in which Pfeiffer points out that only “edification is the dispeller of melancholy.” The second is more systematic in nature with commentaries on each of the principle tenets of the faith and includes references to the Gospel readings for the entire church year. Like Neumeister, Pfeiffer was an Orthodox Lutheran and similar to Neumeister, many of his writings were polemical. But in contrast, Pfeiffer emphasizes the practical application of the church’s teachings rather than strict adherence to its doctrines and, unlike Neumeister, he lauds Spener as one of the “foremost theologians of the day.”

Furthermore, in a section called “the New Birth” (Wiedergeburt), not usually included in such a study, Pfeiffer defines the new birth as “. . . living a spiritual life in Christ through the word and sacraments.” A few pages later he writes, “the spiritual life is . . . the uniting of the soul with Christ.” In concluding this section he writes, “Faith becomes active only through love”—a teaching popular with the Pietists.

In the third work, Pfeiffer discusses the theological differences between the “Reformed, generally called Calvinists,” and Lutherans and explores ways in which the two confessions could reach a “desired state of unity.” When placed in the above context, the three volumes tell us a great deal about Bach’s response to the conflict in Cöthen. Rather than seeking out the writings of a polemicist like Neumeister, he chose those of a conciliator and an admirer of Spener.

December 21 of 1722, Bach applied for the position of Cantor at the Thomaskirche in Leipzig, a post that Telemann had declined a month earlier. On arriving, he found a Lutheran church far different from the one that had forced August Francke to flee in 1689. The church music that he wrote for his Leipzig congregation will form the focus of the remaining portion of this series.

References

Erbe, Hans-Walter. “Zinzendorf und der fromme hohe Adel seiner Zeit” (“Zinzendorf and the pietistic nobility of his time”), 1928. Published in Nikolaus Zinzendorf, Materialien und Dokumente. Bd. 12, Georg Olms, 1975.

Miersemann, Wolfgang. “Lieddichtung im Spannungsfeld zwischen Orthodoxie und Pietismus” (“The Role of Chorale-texts in the conflict between Orthodoxy and Pietism”) Chloe: Beihefte zum Daphnis, Bd. 18, (1994) 177-216.

Spitz, Lewis W. The Protestant Reformation, 1517-1559, Harper, 1985.

Terry, Charles Sanford. Bach: A Biography, London, Oxford University Press, 1928 [Reprint, 1940].

Wolff, Christoph. The New Grove Bach Family, W.W. Norton, 1980.

Zimpel, Herbert. “Der Streit zwischen Reformierten und Lutheranern in Köthen während Bachs Amtzeit” (“The Conflict between the Reformed and Lutherans during Bach’s tenure in Cöthen.”) Bach-Jahrbuch (65) 97-106.

1. By the end of the 17th century, ecumenical relations had in fact become so cordial that the well-known philosopher Leibniz proposed, with Spener’s support, that the two confessions—Reformed and Lutheran—unite into a single church. However, this did not take place until the late 19th century, when Brandenburg’s Reformed, along with those in all but one of the German Reformed states, combined with Lutherans to form a United Church. ↩︎

2. Although idyllic is the word that comes to mind when looking at a print from Bach’s time, the site that greeted me when I first visited Cöthen in the late 1970s was far from that. In 1847 the last prince had died without heirs, and, after World War II, the communist regime had converted the castle into a technical school. The moat, perhaps inadvertently, had become a garbage dump. But when I returned to Cöthen a few months ago on a research trip to Germany, I was able to get a better glimpse of what the court had been in its heyday. The grounds have been cleaned up and restoration work on the castle has begun. The Chapel and the Golden Hall, where Bach had performed with his musicians in the presence of Prince Leopold, are fully restored. ↩︎

3. Its organ, a 60 stop instrument, was built by Arp Schnitger between 1688 and 1693. It survived WWII, and has recently been restored to its original condition. ↩︎

4. Recordings of the Cöthen instrumental works and the Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach are readily available on CD.